Chewy bites of homemade caramel make this easy five ingredient caramel corn recipe a favorite snack or sweet treat for every age.
I think you’re going to find two camps on this one.
First camp: Chewy. Second camp: Crunchy. Count me on Team Gwen Team #1. Chewy all the way.
Just like my favorite granola bars, I favor a chewy, buttery bite to my caramel corn instead of a crack-the-crown-off-your-tooth type of caramel corn.
Call me crazy but my mom and dad didn’t spend all that money on these pearly whites for nothing. I need all my teeth!
For Christmas last year, Smudge got an official, old school popcorn maker from her aunt and uncle. At first I was sort of wondering, why? And where? As in where in the heck am I going to store this sucker? But after using it I’ve certainly found its merits. It makes light and fluffy popcorn each and every time. And I’m okay that it’s stuck in the basement.
Just like in this white chocolate peppermint popcorn treat, I used my favorite popcorn kernel you won’t find at just any old regular grocery store. It’s called mushroom popcorn.
It pops in extra big puffs and rarely leaves those half cooked, un-popped kernels that lodge in your teeth or again, crack a crown. You can find it here.
In This Post
About the Recipe
Being successful at making caramel corn is all about keeping an eye on the caramel and diligently watching that temperature. The ingredients for a chewy caramel corn and a hard caramel corn are exactly the same, it just comes down to how long you cook the caramel.
For a softer, chewier caramel (Camp #2!), cook the mixture only until it hits 235 degrees F. For a harder bite, cook the caramel to 250 degrees F. I use this type of candy thermometer but if you’re into making a tiny bit more of an investment, this one looks even better.
I used our trusty popcorn popper to pop my corn, but if you’re looking for a foolproof stovetop method, this is the one for you.
If you’re into making popcorn balls, simply form the popcorn into shape while still tacky and warm. I find that adding a little softened butter or oil to my hands makes it a lot easier.
I tossed my popcorn with the caramel on a baking sheet but I often use a large bowl to achieve the same effect. Choose whichever suits you.
There are tons of additions you can make to this caramel popcorn to dress it up or down. Think about these flavor combos:
- Make it every man’s dream with chunks of bacon and chili or sriracha powder
- Protein power it with a trail mix of nuts, chocolate chips and raisins
- Make it tropical with dried pineapple, coconut and macadamia nuts
- Eat it cookie monster style with chunks of your favorite cookie chunks
- Drizzle with a combination of melted white and dark chocolate. Add nuts for even more crunch
- Turn it up with s’mores flavors of graham cracker chunks, marshmallows and chocolate
.
The Best Chewy Caramel Corn Plus 5 More to Crunch On
Ingredients
- 1 cup brown sugar firmly packed
- ½ cup light corn syrup
- ¼ cup unsalted butter
- ¼ teaspoon kosher salt
- 4 quarts 16 cups popped popcorn ½ cup unpopped corn kernels
Instructions
- Melt the brown sugar, corn syrup and butter in a medium saucepan. Stir to mix well. Cook until caramel reaches a temperature of 225 degrees F for a chewy caramel, stirring often. Add the popcorn to a large bowl or spread it on a baking sheet topped with wax paper. Top with the hot caramel and toss to coat, mixing well.
- ** For a crunchier caramel corn, cook the caramel to 240-245 degrees F.
