Pasta alla Norma is one of those iconic Italian dishes that if I ever see on a restaurant’s menu, I must order. Just like chicken Parmesan, puttanesca, cacio e pepe, and chicken piccata, I was inspired to find the best way to make it at home. Pasta alla Norma is a Sicilian dish, featuring pasta cloaked in a robust tomato sauce with fried or roasted eggplant, plenty of fresh basil, and topped with freshly grated ricotta salata. It’s the perfect thing to make when eggplants are in season and fresh basil is still plentiful. It’s vegetarian, but hearty, and tastes like late summer.
In This Post
At first glance, it may seem like there are quite a few ingredients in this pasta alla Norma, but it’s actually pretty straightforward and made mostly with pantry staples. Here’s what you’ll need to make it:
For the marinara sauce:
Pasta alla Norma is an easy dish to make. Start your sauce then roast your eggplant while it simmers and thickens (two birds, one stone). It comes together quickly, too. Here’s how to make it:
Crush the tomatoes. Pour the tomatoes and purée into a bowl and crush with your hands or the back of a spoon, then set aside.
Bloom the garlic. In a large cold skillet, add the extra-virgin olive oil and garlic cloves, and bring to medium heat. As the garlic begins to sizzle, stir occasionally, and cook until fragrant and golden, about 5 minutes. Monitor the heat so the garlic doesn’t cook too quickly or burn. Add the red pepper flakes when the garlic is golden so they don’t burn and turn acrid.
Toast the tomato paste. Remove the skillet from the heat and very carefully stir the tomato paste into the garlic and oil—be extra mindful so the oil doesn’t splatter and burn you as the paste is added—and cook for 1-2 minutes.
Simmer, reduce, and thicken. Spoon the tomatoes into the pan with the oil and tomato paste then season with salt and pepper. Add the basil and bring to a boil. Reduce to a bubbling simmer, stirring occasionally, for 30 minutes. Stir to mix the oil that rises to the top, then discard the basil sprigs and garlic.
The biggest question mark for me when developing this recipe (other than to salt or not salt the eggplant prior to cooking—more on that below), was how to cook the eggplant. Traditional recipes have you fry it in a generous pool of olive oil, while some, more recent iterations opt for roasting. I tried my hand at both methods and found that my eggplant had a better, firmer texture after roasting, with some nice caramelization and sweetness that roasting provides. I also like that there’s no turning or babysitting required, and it’s healthier since roasting only employs a fraction of the olive oil. Just make sure you don’t overdo it and end up with eggplant chips!
Slice the eggplant. Preheat your oven to 425°F. Cut the ends off the eggplants. Slice them in half, vertically, then cut them into ½-inch (half-moon) shaped pieces.
Season and roast. Brush a large sheet pan with olive oil and arrange the eggplant pieces in an even layer. If needed, divide the eggplant between two sheet pans. Brush the eggplant tops with olive oil, sprinkle with kosher salt, and place in the oven to roast until golden brown.
There’s long been a debate about salting and draining eggplant before cooking. Some people say salting helps draw out any bitterness. I think it’s more about helping eliminate some of the excess moisture. Salting your eggplant is definitely not mandatory, and for roasting it’s really not necessary. If you were frying or sautéeng your eggplant, I’d advise it, but here you can skip the salt.
Ricotta salata is an Italian sheep’s milk cheese. Unlike ricotta, it has a firm, dry texture and a sharp, salty bite. It’s an important element in pasta alla Norma, but it’s not always easy to find. If needed, substitute pecorino romano, cotija, or even feta cheese. Or, you could do what I like and tear up some fresh buffalo mozzarella then let it melt into the sauce like in my gnocchi pomodoro. It doesn’t have the same bite as ricotta salata, but I can’t resist its rich creaminess.
Pasta alla Norma comes from Catania—a town in the Sicilian region of Italy.
It’s said that the name “pasta alla norma” came from the Italian writer Nino Martoglio, who, upon trying the dish proclaimed it a real “norma” (“masterpiece,” in Italian, and a nod to the Italian opera “Chista è ’na vera Norma!”).